Negative ads leave sour taste

2012-10-07T07:45:00Z Negative ads leave sour tasteBy MIKE MCINALLY, Commentary Albany Democrat Herald
October 07, 2012 7:45 am  • 

LEWISTOWN, Mont. — It’s been snowing here in Montana as an early-fall cold front rolls through the state.

But the real blizzard has been on the state’s airwaves, where one of the nation’s hottest races for the U.S. Senate has been playing out in wave after wave of negative TV ads.

The incumbent, Democrat Jon Tester, is running against the state’s longtime U.S. representative, Republican Dennis Rehberg. It’s a race that would be a big deal in Montana at any time, but it’s taken on national significance since it could affect control of the Senate.

So, like that cold front, millions of dollars have been rolling into the state from all sorts of sources — national political committees and any number of the so-called “super PACs” that were unleashed in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the Citizens United case.

Montana’s sparse population — the state has fewer than 1 million souls — means that it costs a lot less to campaign for a Senate seat here than it does virtually anywhere else in the United States. And with relatively few TV stations, it’s easy to blanket the state with wave after wave of ads — and, it almost goes without saying, most of the political ads on TV in this race are negative.

So if you watch a couple of hours of TV here in the Treasure State — and it could be at any time of the day, even now, with nearly a month until the election — you’ll learn a lot about the horrible actions and deeds of both Tester and Rehberg, two men who actually have served the state relatively well for many years.

What you won’t learn is much at all about the candidates’ positions on any of the important issues facing the United States, or Montana for that matter.

Political experts say that the reason you see so much negative advertising in campaigns is because it works. Maybe that’s true. But it’s hard to imagine how voters can be expected to keep all the charges and counter-charges straight, let alone sort out the kernels of truth from the plentiful chaff of insinuation and misdirection.

By the time you read this, I’ll be back in Oregon, where I’m expecting better weather and fewer negative campaign ads — but that’s because we have few, if any, races attracting national attention and the state doesn’t seem to be in play in the presidential campaign.

So we’re not likely to see the blizzard of negative advertising that voters in Montana are enduring. But we’ll still have to get through a flurry or two before Election Day, and every negative ad will leave us with a sour taste and a nagging sense that there has to be a better way to elect our representatives. (mm)

Copyright 2015 Albany Democrat Herald. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(1) Comments

  1. Mr G
    Report Abuse
    Mr G - October 07, 2012 8:25 am
    Negative political campaigning is part of the American tradition. In 1828 Andrew Jackson supporters called John Quincy Adams a pimp. The Adams campaign countered by claiming that Jackson was the illegitimate son of a prostitute.

    The only thing that has changed since 1828 is technology and the frequency of negative ads. You imply there is a "better way". The hidden question is "who decides"?

    Freedom of speech in its most ugly form is better than government imposed speech codes.

    Political campaigning is messy business. Deal with it.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

where am i logo
50 Objects

Follow Us!

Events Calendar

Login or register to add your events to the calendar! Add event



Will No. 1 seed Kentucky stay perfect to win the 2015 NCAA men's basketball tournament?

View Results

Offers & Announcements

Featured Businesses



Share Your Photos

Staff Photos

Receive Email Updates

Quick notification of big news. Delivered when news breaks (used sparingly).

Top headlines from delivered to you daily.

Get updates about the Beaver sports. Delivered 3 times a week.

Content Match